When looking at the factors that cause people to change jobs, the list can be quite daunting:

  • Poor Leadership and Management Style
  •   Lack of Recognition and Appreciation
  • Inadequate Feedback and Communication
  • Micromanagement
  • Unclear Expectations and Goals
  • Inconsistent or Unfair Treatment
  • Lack of Professional Development Opportunities
  • Poor Conflict Resolution
  • Inadequate Support and Resources
  • Etc.

The familiar line “People don’t leave jobs; they leave bad managers” captures one possible influence, not a universal explanation. Pay, career opportunities, workload, personal circumstances, and other factors can matter too. The practical question is which parts of the experience a manager can improve and how they will learn what needs attention.

In its May 27, 2024 report, Gallup compared perceptions from a nationally representative U.S. sample of 2,729 managers and 12,710 individual contributors. The findings below are dated survey results, not a current assessment of every workplace or proof that power imbalance caused each gap.

The Disconnect Between Managers and Employees

Gallup reported differences between managers’ descriptions of their behavior and employees’ experience of being managed. Use these comparisons as a reason to ask better questions locally, not as scores for your own managers:

Manager Responsiveness

72% of managers believe they respond to messages and calls within 24 hours.

Only 51% of employees agree.

Feedback Quality

69% of managers think they provide quality feedback

Only 50% of employees feel they receive quality feedback.

Approachability

53% of managers consider themselves approachable.

Just 45% of employees agree.

Motivation

32% of managers believe they motivate their teams to perform outstandingly.

Only 22% of employees feel motivated by their managers.

Recognition

59% of managers say they give recognition for good work.

Only 35% of employees feel recognized.

The Problem of Power Dynamic

Authority over work, opportunities, and employment can make upward feedback feel risky. But perception gaps may also reflect different expectations, timing, or what people count as meaningful feedback. Investigate those possibilities rather than attributing every disagreement to fear or dishonesty.

Bridging the Feedback Gap

To address this problem, organizations must focus on training and structural changes that facilitate open and honest communication.

Communication Training

Agree on what useful feedback looks like. Practice a specific observation, its impact, a question that invites the other perspective, and a clear next step. Ask employees what would make the feedback more useful rather than assuming that a generic “Great job!” means the same thing to everyone.

Structured Feedback Sessions

Offer regular one-to-ones and a route outside the direct manager, such as an appropriate HR contact, skip-level leader, or designated independent channel. Explain who receives the information and when it may need to be escalated. Do not require employees to confront their manager before raising a serious concern.

Feedback from Senior Leaders

Senior leaders should model how to receive criticism: listen, ask for examples, and explain the next step without seeking to identify or punish contributors. Set a clear expectation against retaliation, provide a route for reporting it, and review follow-through. Aggregated feedback must be handled carefully where small groups could reveal identities.

Clear Expectations

Feedback often fails when there is a misalignment of expectations. Training managers to set clear and achievable expectations can make feedback more meaningful and actionable for employees.

Comprehensive Management Training

Promoting high-performing employees to management roles without adequate training can lead to ineffective leadership. Comprehensive management training should be a priority to ensure managers are equipped with the skills necessary to lead their teams effectively.

Supporting Managers to Support Employees

Choose one behavior to improve, record the action and owner, and tell employees when progress will be reviewed. Report what changed and what remains unresolved without exposing private feedback. Development needs both practice and follow-through; the existence of a survey alone does not make it safe or useful to speak up.

Better results start with a clearer picture.

When work feels harder than it should, the cause isn’t always obvious. Peoplyst helps leaders find what’s getting in the way across their people, leaders, systems, and execution, then turn those insights into practical action.

Not sure where to start? Take the Peoplyst Alignment Check to explore where your business may be experiencing drag.

The Power Imbalance Between Employees and Managers: A Barrier to Honest Feedback

Scroll to Top

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Newsletter Signup

By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.